Что касается толкования словосочетания "Intent to harm persons" и его производной формы "Assault with a dangerous or deadly weapon". По моему мнению, под "Intent" здесь понимается инициатива и преступное намерение в конфликте. Если хулиган нападает с травматическим пистолетом на законопослушного гражданина для того, чтобы нанести тому телесные повреждения — это определённо попадает под описание "Intent to harm persons".
А если законопослушный гражданин применяет оружие для защиты, то он делает это, в первую очередь, с намерением защитить себя, а не с намерением кого-то искалечить. Телесные повреждения в данном случае являются следствием само-обороны, а не основной целью.
Собственно, к такому выводу и нужно будет склонить консульского служащего на интервью. Для этого, в том числе, нужно будет погуглить по запросам "Self-defence Assault". В сети много полезных материалов по этому поводу. Например, с сайта
ehow:
| Цитата |
|---|
How to Plead Self-Defense to an Assault Charge
Step 1. Hire an attorney who specializes in assault cases. Well-trained lawyers are your best friends when criminal charges are pressed. A good attorney will often know how best to built a case for self-defense, and can advise you on what to do.
Step 2. Explain why assault was the only option. A self-defense argument usually succeeds only if your actions came as a last resort. Be prepared to explain why other means of resolving the situation (such as retreating from the situation or calling the police) were not feasible in your case, and that you risked injury or death if you hadn't acted immediately.
Step 3. Point out that a felony was being committed, or that your assailant struck first. You are legally allowed to defend yourself if the other party is committing, or is about to commit, a crime. You may also legally defend yourself if you were attacked before attacking someone yourself. If you can demonstrate either of these two conditions, you may be able to plead self-defense successfully.
Step 4. Show that the force you used was proportionate to the force with which you were threatened. The law weighs proportion very carefully in these cases. Be prepared to show that you did not escalate the situation, and that you fought back using the same means and force with which you were attacked.
Step 5. Demonstrate that you stopped when your assailant no longer posed a threat. Your ability to plead self-defense successfully may hinge on how much damage you inflicted after your assailant was clearly incapacitated. You should note when you stopped attacking, and be ready to explain why your assailant was still a danger up until that moment. |
